
Damn, PETA. Is there any left to offend?
PETA, I'd like to say a few things to you about this billboard.
1. VEGETARIANISM IS NOT A WEIGHT LOSS PLAN.Why do you want people to be vegetarians? Because they're looking for the newest way to be slim, trim, and beautiful? Or because they actually give a shit about animal rights and want to do their part to end animal cruelty? Does it matter to you?
I have been a vegetarian for many, many years now. I have been a vegetarian for so long that sometimes I forget that people
aren't vegetarians and don't expect everyone they encounter to be a vegetarian. Vegetarianism is, quite simply, part of who I am. My reasons for giving up meat are varied and complex. I had wanted to give up meat for years, through most of my childhood, but what gave me the final push to actually
do it was working in an animal shelter. It became very clear to me: Hamburgers are made from cows, chicken comes from chicken, pork comes from pigs, and those animals are no different or deserving of their cruel fate than the dogs & cats I cared for every day at the shelter. I could not, in good conscience, work with neglected and abused animals while I was on the clock and then eat a hot dog on my lunch break. If I went home and cried about an abused, neglected dog that had to be euthanized, how could I eat a cheeseburger when the animal that cheeseburger was made of was treated just as bad as the animal I was distraught over and met an even more horrible end? I sound like total bleeding heart here and I don't care. I feel strongly about this. I think you can judge a person, and a society, by how they treat their animals. We treat ours horribly. Not only do we treat our "dometicated" pets terribly, like they are disposable toys, we treat our non-pet animals with no consideration and no compassion. What does it say about us? Nothing good. And I want no part of it. Furthermore, we don't
need meat to live. We're omnivores. We can go either way. I feel that if you try to live compassionately and cruelty-free, it tends to spread outward.
Now, I actually did have heatlh reasons for giving up meat. For whatever reason, after I had my gallbladder removed, I just could not digest meat properly. It was miserable. It took awhile for me to make the connection between the awful feeling I got after eating and meat but once I realized I was experiencing what could be compared to "dumping syndrome" (sweating, going cold, chills, just general gastic unease) and cut out the meat, I felt a million times better. And it has had other positive effects on my health. I have healthy blood pressure, healthy cholesterol, my heart functions great, no diabetes, and as I am a Big Girl from a family of Big People with Big People Problems, I credit my heart-healthiness to my vegetarian diet.
HOWEVER. I have not lost any weight as a vegetarian. In fact, I have gained weight. I was at my heaviest when I was vegan. See, vegetarianism is not necessarily synonymous with Eating Healthy. It's a lot easier to be a Junk Food Vegan than a healthy vegan. And the list of vegan snack foods that are readily available is enormous. Hell, Oreos are vegan! Utz potato chips are vegan. French fries are usually vegan too. You can be vegan and still eat quite well. And when I was vegan, I baked a lot. I made vegan cupcakes, vegan muffins, vegan cookies. In massive amounts. You know what makes vegan cookies taste awesome? SUGAR. Lots and lots of sugar. And, if you're an ovo-lacto veggie like me, you have even more ways to get into trouble. And that Purely Decadent Pomegranate Chip soy ice cream I love so much? 800 calories per pint. Seriously. That's a little bit less than your average pint of Ben & Jerry's but still pretty terrible for you. If you're a raw food vegan, well, you will probably lose weight because you will be consuming significantly less calories. But, bottom line, vegetarianism is (in my experience) healthier -- but HEALTHY and THIN are not the same thing and do not go hand in hand.
As a lifetstyle, I think vegetarianism has a lot of benefits, both health-wise and otherwise. But marketing vegetarianism as some sure-fire weight loss plan is just a bold-faced lie.
2. FAT-HATE IS NOT FUNNY, COOL, OR OKAY IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM.I have always been a Big Girl. From the age of 4 or 5 on, really. I was a tubby preschooler. And I pretty much grew up totally hating myself because I was overweight. Sometimes I still do. Sometimes I got so low that I wondered whether life was worth living if I didn't lose weight. I put myself in the hospital because I hated myself and my weight so much and went to extreme measures to make myself thinner. Did I get thinner? Yeah, I did. But I also nearly died and had to spend a week hooked up to an IV. Am I going to blame the media? No. But it sure doesn't help to grow up chubby in a world that tells you that being the way you are is not acceptable. It can be hard to learn to love your curves and extra fluff when society constantly tells you that they are not worth loving and need to be eliminated. Hell, I've known men who have had strange inner struggles with their attraction to bigger gals because having a Fat Girlfriend is seen as some sort of failure of masculinity. The first time a guy seemed to be genuinely attracted to my fluffy self, I could have died of shock. Sometimes I'm still a little surprised when someone thinks I'm all that and a bag of chips.
All the Fat Hate in our culture is not doing anyone any good.
Referring to overweight people (and women, specifically, seem to be who is targeted by this billboard) as "whales" is ludicrous. Seriously, that's the best you got, PETA? 'Whales?" I have heard more creative stabs at fat ladies on the play ground in Kindergarten. And is that what you've sunk to? Playground taughts at fatty? Exactly how is making fun of overweight women helping to further animal rights? Maybe someone will see that billboard and go, "OH WOW. I don't want to be fat like that cartoon lady in the polka dot bikini! I am giving up meat, right here and right now!" That seems unlikely, to say the least.
I suppose I understand what PETA was trying to do with their tactics. Shock people, get them talking, get them thinking. And that's cool. Not my style, but it has its place. But now PETA's tactics
turn people away from the animal rights movement. It gets them talking, but only about how much they hate PETA. And when I tell people I am a vegetarian, sometimes I feel the need to clarify like that I'm not a judgmental jerk and don't get up on my soapbox and condemn all meat-eaters as the Devil Incarnate and won't preach to them about how awful their lifestyle is and that eating a bucket chicken is like being a Nazi. Why? PETA. I think PETA has seriously DAMAGED the cause they're fighting for. And shit like this isn't helping, especially since it's offensive to a ton of vegetarians who also happen to be curvy (and fabulous) ladies.
Maybe it's not worth getting upset about. And by talking about it, I am giving PETA what they want. I AM TALKING ABOUT THEM. But, shit, this billboard is just so wrong. And I find it personally offensive. I am honestly having trouble summing up my thoughts on this issue in a coherent way, but this person did it really well:
Go read this blog post on Vegan Hope. Isa Chandra Moskowitz (vegan chef and author of some really awesome vegan cookbooks) linked to it on her Twitter yesterday and I think it sums up a lot of my feelings on the issue perfectly.